What are the good things you've heard about Italian? I think it's very difficult for an English speaker to learn. First, have you ever set your eyes on Italian grammar? It's way more complicated that English. I'll give you an example of a verb, so that you see it for yourself:
"to cook" has three different forms in English: cook, cooked, cooking. In Italian, the same verb is: cuocere, cuocio, cuoci, cuoce, cuociamo, cuocete, cuociono, cuocevo, cuocevi, cuoceva, cuocevamo, cuocevate, cuocevano, cossi, cuocesti, cosse, cuocemmo, cuoceste, cuocerono, cuocendo, cotto, cotti, cotte, cotta, cuocerò, cuocerai, cuocerà, cuoceremo, cuocerete, cuoceranno.
"Cuocere" is irregular so, it's a bit easier with regular verb (it just means the endings are regular, but their number is the same). The problem is, many verbs are irregular and you have to learn every tense by heart.
Also, you have to conjugate nouns, adjectives and articles (can be feminine, masculine, singular or plural).
It's not easy if you come from a language where grammar is easier.
Pronunciation is easier than English because once you how to read each letter, you are able to read every word. The "u" is always read the same. Pronunciation is not problematic.
Why don't you start with French? Grammar is a bit less problematic than Italian's but there are many words similar in English (since England was once ruled by French native-speakers). Pronunciation is also regular.